ICGFM Promotes Knowledge Transfer Among Public Financial Management Experts

Working globally with governments, organizations, and individuals, the International Consortium on Governmental Financial Management is dedicated to improving financial management by providing opportunities for professional development and information exchange.

Showing posts with label United Nations Independent Advisory Committee.. Show all posts
Showing posts with label United Nations Independent Advisory Committee.. Show all posts

Monday, May 18, 2009

Overview of the Economic Outlook - Synchronized Downturn needs Sustainable Recovery


Robert Vos, Director, Development Policy and Analysis Division, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, United Nations. During his presentation, Mr. Vos introduced a United Nations analysis of the short- and long-term economic outlook. ICGFM members were first to learn about this analysis.



Mr. Vos suggests that the world is experiencing the worst recession since the end of the Second World War. The results suggests a synchronized recession affecting almost every country.

World Economic Situation and Prospects 2009-2010






Mr. Vos introduced the credit crunch in the United States. There has been a reversal in capital flows to developing countries. Around 100 countries will be short of liquidity to service external debt and handle imports. 13 low-income countries are likely to have less than 3 months of liquidity.

World trade has collapsed further than it has since the 1930's. Some observers believe that the collapse has been faster than in the great depression. The report suggests that trade will improve should countries move out of recession.

Mr. Vos discussed the changes in oil prices and the affect of the changes in U.S. dollar valuation and financial investment. Shifts in the oil industry to renewable energy is expected.

Food prices have come down but remain above historic levels. This is a significant burden on people in developing countries. There is systematic underproduction of food around the world. This adds to a worsening worldwide economic situation. The forecast for 2010 ranges from an optimistic growth of 1.6% or pessimistic view of little or no growth.

60 developing countries will see declining incomes, according to Mr. Vos. There has been a severe recession in developed economies. The new members of the EU that had seen high growth has also witnessed a recession. Mr. Vos showed how countries that had experience higher than average growth are now witnessed higher than average recessions.

All developing countries are affected through slowing trade. The primary exporters are also seeing trade deterioration. Low-income, net food and oil-importers are seeing improving terms of trade, but are suffering mainly through reduced demand for exports.

The balance of payments constraints are emerging in growing number of countries and vast reserves are quickly evaporating. Remittances to developing countries have reduced.

There are prospects for recovery, but here are risks that this will be a deeper and more prolonged crisis. Global imbalances may continue. The volatility in the American dollar may be caused by the debt load. This leads to general worldwide economic issues.

There has been an "extraordinary responses to deal with the crisis." Mr. Vos concludes that the "financial landscape has changed".

Mr. Vos believes that bolder action is needed because so much of the stimulus has occurred in some countries, many of whom are running deficits. "Business as usual will not be good enough." Improvements recommended by the United Nations study includes:


  • Decisive and cooperative action is restore the health of financial sector.

  • Fiscal stimulus aligned with global sustainable development objectives

  • Fundamental reforms of the international financial system to overcome the systemic flaws

  • A new framework for global economic governance

U.S. Stimulus: Mismanagement, Fraud and Waste Expected


Is a financial services stress test a real test when it was announced, up front, that no institution would fail? These were some of the questions posed by David M. Walker, President & Chief Executive Officer, Peter G. Peterson Foundation, a the 23rd Annual ICGFM Conference.

Mr. Walker emphasized that "transparency and accountability is good, but not good enough." The United States government does not have a plan to put its own financial management management house in order, according to Mr. Walker. This is a problem for every country in the world

David Walker addressed some of the key factors that led to the current economic situation at the Known for his outspoken observations Mr. Walker, the former Comptroller General of the United States discussed why the financial crisis has had such a global impact and the impact developed and developing countries.

He said that there has been far too much "laggardship" instead of leadership in the public and private sectors in the United States.

Mr. Walker has also been elected as Chairman of the United Nations Independent Advisory Committee. As President and CEO of the Peter G. Peterson Foundation, Mr. Walker was free to say what he wasn't able to do while running the Government Accountability Office. The foundation recently released a report on America's long-term economic perspectives in the international arena.

He pointed out the effects of non typical business cycle challenges , primarily with financial institutions through the bursting of the housing bubble. This generated a ripple effect to other economic activities like the automobile sector. Mr. Walker spoke about how lenders assumed that housing prices would continue to rise and did not exercise good judgement on loans.

Mr. Walker pointed out the lack of transparency in the system. He spoke about the changes to financial instruments that were too complex to borrowers. Governments de-regulated and were not involved in oversight. Greed and short-term thinking further added to the problem. The notion of "being too big to fail" proved to be incorrect, particularly industry icons and financial services.

Only 1/3 of the stimulus package in the United States is related directly to economic stimulus : "timely, temporary and targeted," according to Mr. Walker. Most of the stimulus package relate to other congressional wishes. "We don't know what we are going to get from the money," according to Mr. Walker. There needs to be conditions up front because "once the money flows - it's too late. " Without the appropriate systems and controls up front otherwise there will be fraud, waste and mismanagement.


Mr. Walker, a subject of the documentary I.O.U.S.A., pointed out the the $40 Trillion in long-term "off budget sheet" liabilities for social services in the United States is not accounted for in the deficit. He believes that social security is in a negative cash flow situation or will be within the next 8 years. Today, 50% of the debt is held by foreign debtors.

Mr. Walker pleaded for changes in the United States system that doesn't work. Fundamental reform is needed, in particular to introduce tough budget controls so that Congress cannot spend without knowing the consequences, reform current social services programs and the tax system. The government needs to be more future focused. Better stewardship is needed.

Professional politicians are not inclined to make needed changes and advocate outcome-based measurements.