Aid Policy and Management, the Rwandan Experience

Clement Ncuti, Budget Advisor, Rwanda, described the challenges facing the government in aid effectiveness at the ICGFM Winter Conference. These included:

Human and institutional capacities

• Predictability because of aid conditionality


• High transaction costs


• Requests for unstructured data from donors


• Lack of alignment with government priorities

Mr. Ncuti described the Rwanda aid effectiveness policy. He warned that the challenge is to implement the policy. Lessons were learned to improve the effectiveness of the policy after implementation. Aid effectiveness must be country driven in order to be successful.

The aid effectiveness policy goals of the Government of Rwanda are:

• Use of reliable country systems


• Alignment to national priorities


• Strengthening local capacities


• More predictable aid


• Untied aid


• Use of common arrangements


• Results-oriented frameworks


• Mutual accountability

Mr. Ncuti described the institutional framework in Rwanda for aid policy implementation. He described the criteria for placing aid on budget and the process of aligning aid to country priorities. Medium Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF) is used in the creation of budgets. The Government of Rwanda uses the Development Assistance Database (DAD) and an in-house Integrated Financial Management Information System. These systems are not integrated.

The key lesson learned, according to Mr. Ncuti is the need for mainstreaming of an Aid Policy requires extensive input and ownership over the policy from across government at both technical and political levels

Ncuti aid policy and management, the rwandan experience

View more presentations from icgfmconference.

Ncuti politique d'aide et gestion, l'expérience du rwanda

View more presentations from icgfmconference.

Ncuti política de ayuda y gestión, la experiencia de ruanda

View more presentations from icgfmconference.

Using Government Chart of Accounts for Tracking Aid Flows and Expenditures in the budget4

Tithokoze Samuel, Principal Budget Officer, Ministry of Finance, Malawi, describes the financial management systems in use at the ICGFM Winter Conference. She described the Integrated Financial Management System (IFMIS), use of Treasury Single Account (TSA) and expenditure management.

Ms. Samuel described the limitations of the IFMIS. Many transactions are not controlled by the IFMIS including domestic revenues, domestic debt, external loan, donor projects, payments at the council level. This information is uploaded from other information systems, although the data transfer tends to be a month late.

Ms. Samuel described the footprint of donor aid in Malawi. She described the use of the Aid Management Platform. The Government Chart of Accounts tracks donor support in the budget. However, she pointed out, donors have many different unique codes. She described the four Chart of Accounts segments and the donor codes. She pointed out that getting disbursement information from donors is delayed, yet the IFMIS is real-time. She described the difficulties matching information from the IFMIS and the AMP.

Ms. Samuel hopes that donors can be encouraged to use the IFMIS for disbursements in order to get real-time effective data. The Government COA demands a lot of detail that promotes transparency and accountability, she concluded. It is imperative that cooperating partners not using country expenditure system be encouraged to do so as this reduces time required to produce expenditure reports. She stated that it is possible to track all donor financed projects in the budget and the corresponding expenditures if country systems used.

Samuel using government chart of accounts for tracking aid flows and expenditures in the budget

View more presentations from icgfmconference.

Samuel l’utilisation du plan comptable gouvernemental pour assurer le suivi des flux d’aide et des dépenses dans le budget

View more presentations from icgfmconference.

Samuel utilizar el plan contable del gobierno para registrar los flujos de ayuda y los gastos en el presupuesto

View more presentations from icgfmconference.

Malawi Experience in Aid Information Systems

Aaron Batten, Economist, Ministry of Finance, Malawi, described why aid should be managed at the country level. He described the aid profile of Malawi including funds that are on-treasury, on-budget and on-plan.

Mr. Batten described the problems associated with low technical capacity while managing data from multiple donors within the budget cycle. The Government of Malawi had only ad-hoc information from donors with at least half of the information unavailable to the government. This undermined the budget cycle. He described the process of implementing the Aid Management Platform (AMP) to coordinate aid with the country budget cycle. The biggest challenge was to establish consistent and timely donor reporting to the government.

Mr. Batten described the advantages of using an aid management system in Malawi. Malawi was able to tailor data standards to meet country needs. Donor funds are integrated at aggregate levels, but execution by the government is at a more detailed level. He showed some of the codes.

Mr. Batten found that timely and frequent aid information from donors is more important than accuracy for effective budget control and management. Unless aid information is given to recipients in a very timely manner it is often not very useful for budget control. The Government of Malawi accepts that some of the data may be inaccurate that will need to be fixed later.

Malawi changes classifications and modernizes functions. Therefore, systems much support this type of country level of dynamism according to Mr. Batten. Data needs and priorities change and donors need to be flexible. He concluded that donors need to be responsive and accountable at the country level to enable public financial management reform. The task for recipients is to utilize this information in a way that improves public financial management.

A survey of ICGFM attendees found that almost 1/3 of countries receive no aid information from donors.

Batten aid information management in practise malawi experiences

View more presentations from icgfmconference.

Batten gestión de la información sobre ayuda en la práctica experiencias en malawi

View more presentations from icgfmconference.

Batten gestión de la información sobre ayuda en la práctica experiencias en malawi

View more presentations from icgfmconference.

Technical Solutions and Standards to Bring Transparency to Donor Aid

Samuel Moon, Research Officer, Overseas Development Institute, moderated a panel discussion on aid transparency and the International Aid Transparency Initiative (IATI). Mr. Moon described the history of IATI since the Accra Agenda for Action.

The ODI studied whether budgetary classifications, in the Chart of Accounts, used in developing countries could be consistent with an aid standards. The study examined any common ground amoung budgetary classifications.

Mr. Moon pointed out that large amounts of aid can disrupt the accountability cycle in developing countries. ODI studied information at the donor and country level. 14 countries were selected. The study examined the OECD/DAC CRS and COFOG classifications.

The study focused on the organization and function codes for government charts of accounts. The study uncovered significant similarities among countries however there were limitations in the CRS and COFOG standards. Mr. Moon described some of the budget classification problems such as in the case of where police is found in the Chart of Accounts. He found that the classifications of health functions were inconsistent in the study.

Mr. Moon described the similarities found with the creation of a "spine" classification that could form the basis of a standard. He concluded that interfacing information on aid with budget systems will be country specific.

The paper is available at: http://www.odi.org.uk/resources/details.asp?id=4801&title=aid-effectiveness-agenda-recipient-countries-budget

Moon approches pratiques pour une aide efficace

View more presentations from icgfmconference.

Moon practical approaches to aid effectiveness

View more presentations from icgfmconference.

Moon enfoques prácticos para la efectividad de la ayuda

View more presentations from icgfmconference.